I Want To Be A Roitfeld

Kellina de Boer
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF

Dara Block
STYLE EDITOR

CONTRIBUTING EDITORS
Jessica Eritou
Renee Hernandez
Bernie Rothschild

quoi de neuf
   
Carine Roitfeld

Apartment

Closet

Library

Julia Restoin-Roitfeld

Apartment

Closet

Library

Beauty Products

HOW TO BE A ROITFELD

Beauty Secrets

Style Tips

Recipes

IWTB SHOP

Mademoiselle C

Mademoiselle C (2013)
Directed by Fabien Constant

IWTB Interview:
Fabien Constant

ORDER DVD

VIEW TRAILER

CR FASHION BOOK

Harper's Bazaar

carine roitfeld: irreverent
THE LITTLE BLACK JACKET

I Want To Be An Alt

I Want To Be A Coppola

I Want To Be A Battaglia

IWTB RECOMMENDS

Tom Ford
By Tom Ford

 

Yves Saint Laurent 
By Roxanne Lowit

 

The Big Book of the Hamptons
By Michael Shnayerson

 

A Message for You
By Guy Bourdin

 

Dior: The Legendary Images
By Florence Muller

 

Marella Agnelli: The Last Swan
By Maria Agnelli

 

Fashionable Selby
By Todd Selby

 

O.Z. Diary
By Olivier Zahm 

« Roitfeld Style Tip: Organize Your Closet | Main | Julia Restoin-Roitfeld At Nina Ricci »
dimanche
mars062011

Carine Roitfeld: La Panthère Ose

Milla Msa, editor-at-large in Paris, shares with us her views on the controversial editorial “La Panthère Ose” styled by Carine Roitfeld and shot by Tom Ford for the December 2010/January 2011 issue of Vogue Paris. In the twisted “La Panthère Ose,” Crystal Renn is made to look like a vain, rich cougar, fighting against age for all she is worth, surrounded by a cast of assorted young male models tending to her vanity and aiding in her illusion. Thank you, Milla, for your important message; I hope anyone considering cosmetic surgery will think twice due to your wisdom.

La Panthère Ose
By Milla Msa 

I made no secret of the fact that the December 2010/January 2011 issue of Vogue Paris, guest edited by Mr. Tom Ford himself, was by far the best issue of the year. Carine Roitfeld and Tom Ford are an editorial dream team and therefore a complete delight for the reader. One of their most bizarre editorials from the issue, “La Panthère Ose,” features Crystal Renn post-plastic surgery as styled by Madame Roitfeld and photographed by Monsieur Ford. Knowing how beautiful Crystal is only serves to amp up the shock of seeing her recovering from what I view as pointless operations.

Wearing emerald green Gianvito Rossi sandals and a Carinesque zebra print by Azzedine Alaïa, it is easy to be seduced by those perfectly toned legs and rich-chick jewels but not even a beautiful Lanvin silk scarf can distract from Crystal's bandaged visage as she recovers from a full face lift and nose job. I have seen the documentaries, I know the bandages!

As we progress through "La Panthère Ose," poor Crystal just gets worse and worse. Following the full face lift, we see the beautiful model recovering from a breast augmentation. There she is, gorgeous figure, with her boyfriend (and yes, I mean “boy”) washing her. One can only imagine her pain and her fear. Why do we put bodies through this? Yes, Vogue Paris is distracting us with high fashion pieces but the reality of post-surgery remains the same for the average person. The toy-boys, a well-placed can of Diet Coke, and the bling-bling lend credence to my theory that this woman is looking for something to make her feel complete and relevant: a younger man who despite the pick of younger women wants her, a skinny figure, because in her world that's the only way to be sexy, and most of all, luxury items to keep her feeling like a goddess, all whilst covered in bandages. Oh the irony...

Few images are as powerful and disturbing as Crystal lying back with the blood from her eyelid lift clearly visible and swollen lips as she holds her head and chest in pain, whilst her boy toys attend to her every whim, including ensuring she is wearing just enough Chanel N°5 — vital post-boob lift treatment, of course! Her eyes captivate me and her true fragility is exposed. I feel some connection to this image, some need to share it as I feel like her eyes are asking “How did it come to this?” — I wish I had the answer.

Wearing a silk and python Altuzarra dress and posing with a Tom Ford clad hunk, a scary looking, plump lipped, and feline eyed Crystal shows off her new look much to the horror of the viewer. Gone are the youngsters; she has her new face to make her feel good now. Her sunken cheeks and raised hairline only add to the severity of the look. Ladies, is this really attractive to you? I know people have plastic surgery but nothing pushes me farther from the surgeon's knife than images like this. Imagine what the real thing looks like.

Carine went to great lengths to produce a story so tragic it is almost comical. The relationship among wealth, style, self-worth, and cosmetic surgery is constantly questioned here; how can one be stylish when bandaged up like a mummy? The main question I feel the editorial poses, and one very relevant to all ages, is “How can we understand the beauty of Lanvin, Hermès, and Cartier, yet be blinded to our own natural beauty?” Honestly, I have no idea but I hope that long after my wrinkles become more apparent, I will always view elective plastic surgery as unnecessary and so very unglamorous.

[Editor's note: Julia Restoin-Roitfeld shares her mother's disdain for plastic surgery, recently telling Glamour, “Wrinkles can be beautiful. They’re part of who you are, your charm and your history. And I’m not for plastic surgery — I’d feel like I was cheating on myself."]

Vogue Paris editorial image © 2011 Condé Nast. All Rights Reserved.

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (8)

Money can't buy self-worth. Great commentary, I loved this article.
6 mars 2011 | Unregistered CommenterKate
When people would talk about fashion's impact on their lives, I always thought "get over yourself!" but this editorial continues to have an impact on me and the way I look at myself. The strength of the editorial is that without words, it tells a very vivid tale.

So true Kate, money cannot buy self-worth.

Kellina, happy to hear the gorgeous Julia's comments!
7 mars 2011 | Unregistered CommenterMilla
Well said Milla! It is a struggle to maintain that stance the older you get. I'm surprised that Carine has never had a little somethin' here and there, really? Hmmm. Honestly, I'm not so impressed by Julia. She's too young to be so brash, let's see what she says when she's 40.
I've personally dodged the needle but aging is a hard thing to accept. I would imagine much more difficult if you are in the fashion/beauty industry.
Cupcake
xo
7 mars 2011 | Unregistered Commentercupcake
Hm, interesting topic, it's great to hear the commentary on it! Great post.

http://betweenmargins.blogspot.com
7 mars 2011 | Unregistered CommenterBex
Thanks, Kate! Glad you like! I think Milla did a wonderful job with this piece.
8 mars 2011 | Registered Commenterkellina
Milla, thank you again for sharing your opinion, loves it!
8 mars 2011 | Registered Commenterkellina
Cupcake, she says she's never even touched Botox, let alone gone anywhere near the knife. I dunno. As for Julia, you are right, she hasn't even begun aging so she can speak confidently now, but let's give her another decade...

; )

xoxo
8 mars 2011 | Registered Commenterkellina
Thanks, Bex! Great to hear from you.
8 mars 2011 | Registered Commenterkellina

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.